Elementary, HIMYM, Nashville

Elementary

A female detective needs to look and act tough, but there's no reason why can't take a walk on the feminine side, too. Joan nails that mix with this black leather jacket, sleek black tights, and boots (tough), paired with a bow-print shirt (feminine). You can go shopping and "do lunch" with her, and afterwards, confidently walk down a dark alley, knowing she will kick the ass of anyone who dares harass you. Heck, she even has to prop up a blubbering Sherlock when he sees a "ghost" at the end of the episode. Sigh, Lucy Liu has to take care of everything on this show, doesn't she? — Kim Humes

How I Met Your Mother

OMG, #wemetthemother. And she's the most adorably doe-eyed pixie ever. I applaud the casting choice (you know Ted would go for "cute", not "hot") and does she not look like a cross between Robin and Lily? Clearly, Mother is a laid-back sort of gal, what with her worn-in boots and sweet crochet dress, but the bright yellow umbrella screams "QUIRKY!" Plus, Cristin Milioti plays the ukulele, so strap in for lots of goofy shenanigans and fit-n-flare dresses next season. — Jen Luby

Nashville

In the land of sequin, glitter, rhinestones, and more sequins, it can sometimes be hard to tell who's best dressed vs worst dressed. Tacky abounds, y'know? But when Maddie showed off her father/daugther dance dress, it not only took Rayna and Teddy's breaths away, it took mine too!

First of all, it was highly appropriate for a 13 year old. And you know how we like appropriateness around here. Second, it was shiny and glittery without being over the top. And don't even get me started on her adorbs up-do. For being a superstar's daughter, Maddie could have totally come out looking like a Lourdes or even a Willow Smith. Thankfully, she kept it tasteful. Stay classy, Nashville. — Kate O'Leary

Hart of Dixie, Modern Family, Mr Selfridge

Hart of Dixie

I don't know about you, but as soon as I get on a plane, my style factor plummets from Prada to Skymall. But not Dr. Zoe Hart! She's rocking the chic-ly serious blazer with a relaxed fit blouse underneath, plus some artfully ripped jeans. Not only did she not bring a snack for the plane, she's reading an actual book. AND performing emergency procedures on a fellow passengers! Meanwhile, sitting in a row behind her is me, wrapped up my University of Maryland sweatpants and hoodie, eating the complimentary peanuts, and reading Skymall. Zoe, we have so much to learn from you. — Matt Solyst

Modern Family

On last week's Modern Family, Lily got $100 for her tooth because the tooth fairy (*coughCAMcough*) had a bit too much vino. Luckily, her dads have a niece who's willing to don a pink wig, crown, wings, and a tutu and play the tooth fairy (I know, Cam was secretly devastated he couldn't do it). It's too bad that Haley tripped up and "tooths" instead of "teeth" because nothing gets past Lily and her clutch, which transitions seamlessly from daycare to bedtime while holding crayons...and a hundred dollar bill. — Steph Au

Mr Selfridge

This week's period costume goodness is brought to you by Lady Mae, who does a little light shopping/scheming in this fetching navy day dress, complete with a huge HBIC hat. Go back and watch the episode. With feathers like that, she had no trouble pursuading the fuddy-duddy bankers to take Mr. Selfridge's crazy American ideas into consideration.

BY THE WAY, did you notice that later in the episode she re-wore the aubergine gown from the pilot? Royalty...they're just like us! — Jen Luby

Would Their Characters Wear That? (YKYLF stars at the 2013 Met Gala)

So, the Met Gala was last night. And while a red carpet situation is generally an opportunity to report snark on our stars' styles, that's hard to do when there's a theme afoot (this year's was Punk: Chaos to Couture). So instead, we wondered — what would their characters say about these looks? Would they totally wear that, or would they cluck in disapproval?

Ladies Don't Do Punk Michelle Dockery in Burberry	online polls
Jaime King in Topshop	polls
January Jones in Chanel	online polls
Allison Williams in Joseph Altazarra	survey software
Not a Stretch Jessica Paré in Jason Wu	online survey
Sarah Jessica Parker in Giles Deacon and Philip Treacy	surveys
Quirky! (Awkward?) Lena Dunham in Erdem Moralioglu	polls
Zooey Deschanel in Tommy Hilfiger	surveys & polls
Vamps Wear Black Nina Dobrev in Monique Lhuillier	survey tool
Alexander Skarsgard in Calvin Klein	survey software

The Americans, Elementary, Scandal

The Americans

Oh, honey. So this week, Philip cemented his fake relationship with Martha (and convinced her to bug her FBI boss's office) by agreeing to marry her. Like, that day. After the worlds shortest engagement, they had the world's most awkward wedding, featuring Elizabeth and Granny as Philip's fake family members/witnesses. Even a desperate singleton like Martha had to have been a little sad about this courthouse wedding. At least she was working the retro 80s glamour with this baby blue dress (and matching blue eyeshadow). Too bad she's not allowed to tell anyone they got married, or live together. Also, shame how the entire thing is just a lie to get her to betray her country. Oh, honey. — Ann Foster

Elementary

This week Sherlock and Watson try to solve the mystery of Watson's dress. Where did the shoulders go? Why are the sleeves half made of lace? Is it a shirt dress gone horribly wrong? Unfortunately, it's a mystery that will remain unsolved. Much like why Sherlock is determined to hide how hot he actually is behind shirts buttoned too high. — Lesley-Anne Steeleworthy

Scandal

Seeing as Liv spent 95% of this week’s episode in a hospital gown, it was time for Abby to step up her fashion game. She stoically took on the responsibilities of helping a distraught Huck AND dressing to impress. Abby’s speech to Huck left much to be desired, but her 60s inspired hair paired with peasant-style top and high-waisted skirt truly hit the mark. Abby, keep showcasing this style, and I’ll listen to your depressing pep talks anytime.
— Terry Beasley

Mr Selfridge, Project Runway, Vampire Diaries

Mr Selfridge

This week, Harry's philandering and partying ways caught up with him in a spectacular auto accident, just after he was accosted by his former lady love, Ellen Love. Sure, she may have been doped up and pathetically groveling at Harry's feet, but she looked fab from the neck down in this timeless black sequined gown accented with an opal necklace and earrings. Opals are bad luck, Ellen...didn't anyone ever tell you that? Then again, it's probably your behavior and not your jewelry that have landed you in such a mess. Just a hunch. — Jen Luby

Project Runway

As this is Part I of this season's finale, i.e. the one with the full collections, you'd think I would pick one of the designers' creations as my fave of the week. But no. As soon as I saw this cat-head brooch on Michelle, all the other outfits disappeared from my memory. Ask anyone who has talked to me longer than 5 minutes — I am a crazy cat lady, not to mention a lover of quirky accessories. What about the rest of her outfit? Who CARES?! Cat. Brooch, people. This girl could do an entire collection just based on this brooch and I would buy every piece. Here's my tip for making it work, Michelle - just stick this cat's head on every outfit you show at Lincoln Center and you'll be sure to win the whole thing! — Kim Humes

Vampire Diaries

Guess what, guys? It's prom season in Mystic Falls! And with any prom comes dress drama. Elena may have stolen Caroline's first dress (that gorgeous Theia gown at right) but Caroline has her very own fairy godmother — Klaus. And Klaus definitely succeeded in fulfilling Caroline's wish for a dress "fit for a Princess". The seed pearls, intricate beading and mermaid tulle skirt are gorgeous, and suit Caroline even better than her old gown. Suck it, Elena.
— Steph Au