While Dan’s chest hair played hard to win the game and Fauxmanda consistently brought inappropriate to new levels, they were no match for these two.



Sutton (The Lying Game) vs Annie (90210)
This is a west coast showdown between the girl with the secret twin and the secret plan, and the girl who used to be a secret call girl escort (no, Annie, we’re not going to let you live that down).

When she’s got access to The Magic Closet, Sutton is never without a) a structured blazer and b) a bitchface. Even if she’s meeting her long-lost twin at a bus station at 8:50am. Meanwhile Annie is never without a) exposed midriff and b) maxi skirt. Even if she’s existing in the year 2012.


Who’s the most inappropriate? Voting ends at 11:59p Central on 3/24
Voting has now closed. Check back soon for the Final Four!